British Columbia Law
Adult Guardianship BC: What Happens When Family Members Disagree
<p>When an elderly parent or spouse loses the ability to make decisions for themselves, families often discover that they don't agree — about what care the person should receive, where they should live, how their money should be managed, or who should be in charge.</p>
<p>These disputes are painful. They happen at an already difficult time. And without the right legal documents in place, they can spiral into costly court proceedings that leave the vulnerable person caught in the middle.</p>
<h2>How BC Law Handles Incapacity</h2>
<p>In BC, if someone becomes mentally incapable and has no Representation Agreement or Enduring Power of Attorney, the options are limited and formal:</p>
<ul>
<li><strong>Committee appointment</strong> — A family member (or other person) can apply to the BC Supreme Court under the <em>Patients Property Act</em> to be appointed "committee" — a legal guardian with authority over the person's affairs</li>
<li><strong>Public Guardian and Trustee</strong> — If no one applies, or if there's a dispute, the Office of the Public Guardian and Trustee of BC can step in to manage the person's finances and sometimes their personal care</li>
<li><strong>Adult guardianship</strong> — Under the <em>Adult Guardianship Act</em>, a designated agency can investigate concerns about vulnerable adults and apply for support and assistance orders</li>
</ul>
<h2>When Family Members Disagree</h2>
<p>The most common disputes involve:</p>
<ul>
<li>Who should be appointed committee — typically when multiple siblings each want the role, or when one sibling objects to another's appointment</li>
<li>Whether a person truly lacks capacity — sometimes one family member believes the person is still capable while another does not</li>
<li>Care decisions — disagreements about whether the person should live at home, with a family member, or in a care facility</li>
<li>Financial management — concerns that one family member is mismanaging or misappropriating the incapacitated person's money</li>
</ul>
<p>The BC Supreme Court has broad authority to resolve these disputes, but proceedings take months and cost tens of thousands of dollars. During that time, important decisions may be delayed or made by the court on an interim basis.</p>
<h2>The Role of Capacity Assessments</h2>
<p>BC has a formal capacity assessment process. Designated capacity assessors — typically psychologists, psychiatrists, or trained nurses — can conduct assessments and issue certificates that carry legal weight. A capacity certificate can trigger the Public Guardian and Trustee's involvement, or support a committee application.</p>
<p>If a family member disputes the assessment, the court may order an independent assessment.</p>
<h2>How to Avoid This Entirely</h2>
<p>The simplest way to prevent family disputes about incapacity is to plan before it happens. A properly executed Representation Agreement names one (or more) representatives, sets out the scope of their authority, and can include a dispute resolution process if representatives disagree. An Enduring Power of Attorney names an attorney for financial matters.</p>
<p>When these documents are in place and properly drafted, there is rarely a dispute — because the incapacitated person has already made their wishes legally clear.</p>
<p>If you are concerned about an elderly family member's capacity, or if a dispute has already begun, legal advice early in the process can prevent it from becoming a prolonged court battle.</p>
This article is general information, not legal or tax advice. Meetings are by appointment only, by phone or secure video.